Enjoy Every Fish Fry: Milwaukee and Wisconsin fish fry reviews

January 18, 2024

Caleb Westphal hasn’t missed a Friday fish fry since 2013. This is a list of all the Wisconsin fish fry reviews he’s written for Milwaukee Record, beginning in 2017, organized by city. (Certain places may have since closed, changed names, etc.)

APPLETON

Mark’s East Side

BIG BEND

Blue Heron Supper Club

BROOKFIELD

Butch’s Red Mill

Pistol Pete’s Pizza And Neighborhood Grill

Sluggo’s Sports Pub & Grill

BUTLER

CALEDONIA

C & C’s Mosquito Inn

The Depot Tavern

Husher’s Pub & Grill

Tailgaters Bar & Grill

CAMPBELLSPORT

Sandpiper Inn

CEDARBURG

The Farmstead

Morton’s Wisconsinn

CHICAGO (IL)

Millie’s Supper Club

Will’s Northwoods Inn

COLGATE

Joe Mama’s Bar & Grill

CUDAHY

Joe’s K Ranch

Light Palace Pub & Grill

DELAVAN

The Duck Inn Supper Club

DODGEVILLE

EAST TROY

Lulabell’s Dockside

FOND DU LAC

Blanck’s Lake Aire

Walleye Weekend (2017)

Walleye Weekend (2018)

FORT ATKINSON

Fireside Theatre

Stagecoach Inn

FRANKLIN

Country Lanes

Hideaway Pub & Eatery

Mulligans Irish Pub & Grill

Polish Center Of Wisconsin

Ricky’s Double Barrel Inn

Romey’s Place Bar & Grill

Swagger Sports Bar & Grill at Root River Center

Swiss Street Pub & Grille

Wegner’s St. Martins Inn

FRANKSVILLE

Joey’s West

GERMANTOWN

Lone Star Tavern

GLENDALE

The Bavarian Bierhaus

The Brick Pub & Grill

Johnson’s Green 7

Silver Spring House

GRAFTON

Juice’s Ghost Town

GREEN BAY

Maricque’s

GREENDALE

Carl’s Catering

Joey Gerard’s

The Steakout

GREENFIELD

Club Paragon

Meyer’s Restaurant And Bar

On The Edge Bar & Grill

Ray’s Butcher Shoppe

HALES CORNERS

Ann’s Italian Restaurant

Clifford’s Supper Club

Stoneridge Inn

HARTFORD

Little Red Inn

The Mineshaft

HARTLAND

The Phoenix

HAYWARD

Lost Land Lake Lodge

HUBERTUS

Bilda’s Friess Lake Pub

The Copper Dock

The Fox & Hounds Restaurant & Tavern

Johnny Manhattan’s

Sloppy Joe’s Saloon & Spoon

KANSASVILLE

Michael’s On The Lake

KENOSHA

Birchwood Grill

Union Park Tavern

LANNON

Mibb’s & Viv’s

MADISON

Dexter’s Pub

Jordan’s Big 10 Pub

MANITOWOC

Tower Tavern

MENASHA

Club Tavern

MENOMONEE FALLS

A.J. O’Brady’s Irish Pub & Grill

Belly Up Bar

The Schwabenhof

The Social Haus

MEQUON

Landmark Inn

Range Line Inn

Spanky’s Hideaway

White Rabbit Bar & Grill

MILFORD

Crawfish Junction

MILWAUKEE

68th Street Pub

Aliota’s Pub & Grill

Allgauer’s Bistro & Pub In The Park

Baby Boomers

Barnacle Bud’s

Beer Belly’s (pickup)

Brass Key Restaurant & Lounge

Brewski’s Sports Club

Brewtown Eatery

Buck Bradley’s

Brown Bottle

Café Centraal

Café el Sol

Club Charlies (pickup)

Coach’s Pub ‘N’ Grill

Company Brewing

County Clare

Crafty Cow (pickup)

Crazy Water (pickup)

Culver’s (Layton Avenue)

Don’s Diner (pickup)

Emerald City Catering & Events

Explorium Brewpub (via The Hop)

Final Approach

Flannery’s Bar & Restaurant

Fritz’s Pub

Grainger’s Pub & Grill

Hacienda Beer Co.

Honeypie (pickup)

Hooligan’s

In Plane View

J&B’s Sports Bar & Blue Ribbon Taproom

Just Art’s Saloon

Kam’s Thistle & Shamrock

Klemmer’s Banquet Center

Klinger’s East

Lakefront Brewery

Landmark 1850 Inn

Lucky’s Ice House Bar & Grill

Magoo’s On The Mound

Major Goolsby’s

Maverick’s

McBob’s Pub & Grill

Milwaukee Elks Lodge #46

Mistral (pickup)

Motor Bar & Restaurant

Mr. J’s Lounge

Mr. Perkins Family Restaurant (pickup)

OG Pub & Grille

O’Brien’s Pub

O’Lydia’s Bar and Grill

Old German Beer Hall

On The Clock Bar & Grill

Oscar’s Pub & Grill

The Packing House (pickup)

Pat’s Niche Pub And Grub

Pitch’s Lounge And Restaurant

Points East Pub

Ruby J’s (with Milwaukee County Executive David Crowley)

Sabrosa Café & Gallery

Saz’s State House

Schneider’s Food & Drinks

Scotty’s Bar & Pizza (pickup)

South Shore Terrace

Spitfires On State

St. Augustine Of Hippo

St. Florian Parish

St. Gregory the Great

St. Paul Fish Company (Milwaukee Public Market)

St. Sebastian Parish

Steny’s Tavern & Grill (pickup)

Swingin’ Door Exchange

Tess (pickup)

The Tracks Tavern & Grill

Twisted Fisherman

Venice Club (Summerfest)

Villanas Night Club

Ward’s House Of Prime, Trinity Three Irish Pubs, Venice Club (Summerfest)

The Wicked Hop

Zak’s Café

MUKWONAGO

Brookwood Inn

MUSKEGO

Bass Bay Brewhouse

Country Squire Supper Club

Danny Haskell’s Pub & Grill

The Gingerbread House

The P&B Station

TJ’s Roundabout

NEW BERLIN

Matty’s Bar & Grille

Rainbow Restaurant

Varsity Club

NEWBURG

Parkside Inn

NORTH LAKE

North Lake Bear Trap

OAK CREEK

The Cellar Pub & Grill

Erv’s Mug

Jim Dandy’s

Oak Creek American Legion Post 434

South Bound Again

OCONOMOWOC

Stolley’s Hogg Alley

OKAUCHEE LAKE

Kick Switch Bar And Grill

OSHKOSH

Parnell’s Place

PALMYRA

Nite Cap Inn

Squidy’s 2

PEWAUKEE

5 O’Clock Club

The Station Pub & Grill

PLEASANT PRAIRIE

Village Supper Club

PORT WASHINGTON

Moonlight Tavern & Supper Club

RACINE

Cliff’s Boathouse Café

The Foxhole Lounge

Oh Dennis! Saloon & Charcoal House

RICHFIELD

Sawmill Inn Restaurant & Pub

RICHFORD

Johann’s Bar & Grill

ROCHESTER

ROXBURY

Dorf Haus Supper Club

SHOREWOOD

North Shore American Legion Post #331

SISTER BAY

Sister Bay Bowl

SOUTH MILWAUKEE

Muskie’s Gourmet House

Pat’s Oak Manor

Slick Willies

Spirits Bar & Grill

Thirsty’s

ST. FRANCIS

The Landing

Polonez Restaurant

The Saucy Swine / Redbar

St. Francis Brewery

THIENSVILLE

Chuck’s Place

Skippy’s Burger Bar

UNION GROVE

TinCAN Roadhouse

VAN DYNE

Wendt’s On The Lake (with Don Gorske)

WATERTOWN

Elias Inn (with Sen. Tammy Baldwin)

WAUKESHA

Andrea’s Red Rooster

Cue Club Of Wisconsin

The Neighbors Bar & Grille

Tally’s Tap & Eatery

Waukesha Eagles Club Aerie 453

WAUTOMA

WAUWATOSA

Colonel Hart’s

Leff’s Lucky Town

Sts. Constantine & Helen Greek Orthodox Church

Ted’s Ice Cream & Restaurant

Walters’ On North

WEST ALLIS

Dicken’s Grille & Spirits

The Farmer’s Wife

Guzzlers Sports Lounge

Henry Flach’s

JC’s Pub And Grub

Kegel’s Inn

Kegel’s Inn (catered)

Kokopelli’s Pub & Grub

Limanski’s Pub

Mother Of Perpetual Help Parish

Paulie’s Pub & Eatery

Randy’s Neighbor’s Inn

Slim’s Lakefront Brew Pub & Eatery, Door County Fish Boil (Wisconsin State Fair)

State Fair Inn

Steak House 100

WEST MILWAUKEE

WHITEFISH BAY

Jack Pandl’s Whitefish Bay Inn

WIND LAKE

B-Lazy Bar & Grill

Want more Caleb? Hire him for all your 100%-vinyl DJ needs and follow him on Patreon.

RELATED ARTICLES

• The best fish frys in Milwaukee (and beyond)

• Fish fry archive