In MKE Music Rewind we revisit notable Milwaukee music that was released before Milwaukee Record became a thing in April 2014. In this installment: Buffalo Gospel’s 2013 album We Can Be Horses.

On Saturday, November 21, Buffalo Gospel will take the stage at The Cooperage. Over the last 10-plus years, a late autumn Milwaukee outing by the alt-country outfit has become something of a tradition for a faction of folks in the city. Though the ritual of seeing the band headlining a hometown performance happening sometime in the general of vicinity of the Thanksgiving holiday will continue for another year, the annual occurrence has changed in a variety of ways over the past decade or so.

The show has bounced around between sites like The Cooperage, Anodyne Coffee’s Walker’s Point Roastery, the now-defunct Back Room @ Colectivo, and Vivarium. Openers have fluctuated, with certain projects outright ending and others outgrowing the support slot. Some Buffalo Gospel members have departed and new musicians have taken their place. Among that current crop of core contributors, some have relocated to other states. The band’s name has even changed to Ryan Necci And The Buffalo Gospel, reflecting the bandleader and project’s now-namesake now making his living as a professional songwriter in Nashville.

While the band’s name, lineup, individual places of residence, chosen venues and openers have all undergone significant changes through the years, and the Gospel’s catalog has also expanded with new releases and augmented through ongoing artistic evolution during that span, the central themes of this fall Milwaukee music tradition are still alive and well. Listeners leave the house on a cold night in November or December to converge in a room and listen to gorgeous music anchored by heartfelt lyrics about love, loss, and the human condition. And just has it’s always been the case amid a world of perpetual and inevitable change, some of the songs played each and every year will come from We Can Be Horses.

Though it was technically preceded by two EPs, We Can Be Horses is effectively the debut of Buffalo Gospel as we’ve come to know it. The 2013 album finds Necci—the founder, bandleader, primary songwriter, and only remaining member from the project’s outset—enlisting the likes of Heidi Spencer and Allen Coté (both of whom were and still are accomplished solo artists in their own right) and other backing players highlighted by prolific mandolin aficionado Ryan Ogburn to fill in the sturdy scaffolding on a dozen emotionally wrought compositions.

The record opens with the breezy “Song Of The Ox” before settling into a place of quiet rumination that consists of standout tracks like the solitary march that is “Mule,” the captivating gratitude on the lilting “Hoarse As A Crow,” the mournful “When God’s Away On Business,” and the musical reimagining of letters from Necci’s uncle on “The Northern” that’s equal parts tragic and beautiful. The winning pattern of light and lyric-forward songs is briefly broken by the hazy and guitar-driven likes of “The Eastern” and the rollicking and uptempo “If I Was The Last Man” before setting back to Buffalo Gospel’s bread and butter—songs from the heart delivered conveyed with gorgeous harmonies and delicate instrumentation—as expertly illustrated on late-album stunner “All That I Got Left.”

We Can Be Horses was followed by On The First Bell in 2018, an outstanding effort which garnered attention in county- and Americana-adjacent circles far beyond Wisconsin’s border and ultimately prompted Necci to make the move to Music City. Since then, the band’s repertoire has grown by way of its Battle Cry EP and last year’s third album, The Dead Can’t Take A Hint. Though things are noticeably different with the band now known as Ryan Necci And The Buffalo Gospel compared to 10-plus years ago, the tradition of a Milwaukee performance in late autumn will thankfully continue another year and you can bet those gathered at The Cooperage this weekend are still going to hear a handful of songs from We Can Be Horses along the way.

Let’s hope that never changes.

About The Author

Avatar photo
Co-Founder and Editor

Before co-founding Milwaukee Record, Tyler Maas wrote for virtually every Milwaukee publication (except Wassup! Magazine). He lives in Bay View and enjoys both stuff and things.