Crafty Cow likes to keep things interesting. Since opening its first location in Oconomowoc in 2014, the regional restaurant chain—which also has locations in Milwaukee and Wauwatosa—evolved from its initial “juicy lucy”-style burger focus and gradually added fried chicken (including one of the area’s best Nashville hot chicken sandwiches) to the mix.
Along the way, they dabbled in ramen, added fish fry, brought in brunch, and even devoted portions of its Milwaukee and Tosa properties to its Outlaw Oyster seafood concept. Recently, Crafty Cow has garnered oodles of social media attention for yet another menu offering that few would’ve ever expected to be the restaurant’s so-called “viral” item and new best-seller: a Chicken Caesar Wrap.
Crafty Cow has been serving a Chicken Caesar Wrap—a comparatively “lighter” and ever-so-slightly more healthy offering than much of the restaurant’s largely indulgent fare—since 2025. It quietly existed on the menu, overshadowed by far more decadent dining Crafty creations, until about a month ago. Thanks to a mixture of marketing savvy and, more so, making significant changes to the previously pretty standard take on a handheld, the new and improved Chicken Caesar Wrap has become a top-selling item and has brought a much-needed boost in business during a particularly difficult time for restaurants.
@craftycowwiWhether you pulled up for the Caesar Wrap or you’ve been loyal to us before the hype—we see you, and we appreciate you. The support lately has meant the world. All hail the Caesar Wrap 🙌♬ 1901 – Instrumental – Phoenix
Just as Stranger Things helped to introduce Kate Bush to a new generation of listeners, the primary reason for the Caesar Wrap’s sudden renaissance is undoubtedly what one critical TikTok commenter referred to as the “Performative Parmesan” that’s grated atop the re-imagined entree. However, that’s just one of many changes it has experienced during its glow-up.
Owner Devin Eichler tells us the chese used inside of the wrap is different than it used to be. Breaded and fried chicken tenders now take the place of grilled poultry. The tomatoes and croutons have been 86ed and the lettuce is now diced differently than it once was. Once mixed and liberally dressed with creamy house Caesar, the fresh and hefty blend is crammed into a new, larger tortilla wrapping and crisped on a flat top.
View this post on Instagram
Having partaken in the original iteration and being lured back in to try the updated wrap on account of the recent social media resurgence, we can confirm the difference between then and now is night and day, and that it absolutely lives up to the hype. Evidently, we’re not alone in thinking that. Eichler says Crafty Cow is now averaging over 3,000 wraps sold each month, up from the 300/month average it used to sell. Its next top-seller, the Crafty Classic burger, sells about 2,000 per month.
Early on after the wrap’s revision, there were literally lines out the door at the Bay View (where the wrap still performs best) and Tosa locations. And the significant influx in business has allowed Crafty Cow to add more server and kitchen positions at all three locations. It’s also inspired Eichler (a self-described Caesar Wrap appreciator) to focus on making food that he really loves.
“I think the way we are looking at it now is not going viral, but let’s continue to just get better. Let’s continue to take what we do and elevate it,” Eichler says. “When we make a new item, do we all fucking love it as much as this Caesar Wrap?”
Somehow, a Chicken Caesar Wrap of all things—typically the definition of “and more” when we write about menus and the prototypical “work lunch” option you settle for—has legitimately transformed into a top-three menu stunner at Crafty Cow, an actual job creator, and a reason for appointment eating at a restaurant you know for its Nashville hot, its specialty burgers, hot honey cheese curds, and seafood side-hustle. Who could’ve predicted that?
Hail Caesar indeed!
