Milwaukee lost a real one this month. Art Guenther, owner of Just Art’s Saloon on 181 S. 2nd St., died at age 80 on August 14, 2025. For his closest friends and his community of regulars who found themselves year after year at this true old-school hole-in-the-wall in Walker’s Point, this wasn’t just the loss of a friend—it was the end of an era in which barkeeps once served as nuclei for a whole neighborhood, keeping the past alive in the very way they conduct their business.
Who was Art Guenther? Saloon owner, sure. But also: merch peddler, storyteller, neighborhood historian, dice roller. Pretty bad bartender. Pretty good cook. In photos, he is often leaning forward on the bar, engaging a beer-gripping audience in one of his many life stories.
Art led an interesting life and had a skill for narrative arcs, so his yarns were worth ones attention. He had an encyclopedic memory and a sense of humor that was at times crass, morbid, and surprising. As soon as you had a drink in your hand, Art would show you his Just Art’s Saloon merchandise, which included shamrock key chains, trucker hats, fanny packs, sweatpants, and more, the prices of which were hardly set in stone. You could always go to Art’s for a laugh and to learn something new about the world. If you were new to the bar he would show you a music video where he appears, briefly, leaning off the deck, grinning at his certain fame.
Or he would pull out his California driver’s license from 1969, issued when he was 22 years old and living in Newport Beach. It was torn and creased from many years inside his wallet, but the stony young man in the image had the same broad nose—his thick hair swooped in the same direction—as the grinning bespectacled man prying the cap off another beer.
When he died, locals and regulars took to the socials and exchanged their memories of Art in a way that began to clarify the community he had built over time. Their memories of his wit and candor could make even a stranger to the bar feel like they’d been bellying up to Art’s for years. Here’s the thing: if you took Art out of Just Art’s Saloon, you’d be hard pressed to find a reason to ever visit the damn place. Always dim and kinda crusty, Just Art’s didn’t hold much appeal based on inventory or atmosphere. It existed exactly as it was and made no moves to please anyone in particular, let alone everyone. The reason you went to Just Art’s Saloon was to drink a cheap, familiar beer and to hang out with Art.
Here’s the other thing: there’s a lot of fear and pain and isolation in the world, most of it made more so by our dwindling access to local community. Just Art’s may not have always had toilet paper in the women’s bathroom, but it had a hodgepodge family of regulars who stumbled into the bar as college students 30 years ago and just kept returning. As one of those regulars told me, Art had a way of collecting opinionated waywards, becoming “a friend of the friendless” to those who crossed into his bar. He was observant and conniving and charming and kind. The world could use more bars with a guy like Art pouring your drink.
When does a bar become something other than an establishment? Maybe it’s based on beer selection (slim), or cleanliness (questionable), or legacy (longstanding). Maybe it’s based on history and a stubborn refusal to change as the neighborhood grows and glimmers outside a creaky door. In many ways, Art Guenther didn’t run a bar so much as he ran a gathering place. He threw so many parties—inventing reasons to feed his regulars and wanderers alike, to draw more witty and interesting people into his orbit. Thank goodness Just Art’s Saloon was never just a saloon.
Want more Milwaukee Record? Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter and/or support us on Patreon.