Sunday Sauce is a monthly Milwaukee Record series about the area’s Italian food and the places, people, and traditions that make a meal feel like home. I’m chasing how these restaurants, grocery stores, events, and small details keep feeding people into comfort, community, and a sense of belonging in a loud world. This chapter of Sunday Sauce is supported by The Florentine Opera and its upcoming production of La Traviata.

Caught in the shadow of the Smithfield bacon factory, beneath the beacon of the Cudahy water tower, and just beyond the rumble of ATI’s drop forge hammer sits a beige-and-brick building with red letters promising pizza: Papa Luigi’s (3475 E. Layton Ave.; 414-483-6111).

Papa Luigi’s has been serving Cudahy since 1983, when Sal Purpora first opened the family-run neighborhood restaurant. Forty-three years isn’t especially old for a person, but for an independent, family-owned and operated neighborhood restaurant, it’s long enough to become a generational cornerstone of a community. Walking in from the parking lot out back, you’re greeted by a Hall of Fame-esque collection of Italian-American menagerie of iconic crooners, before coming face-to-face with a life-sized, blatantly cartoonish statue of a lounging Al Capone, who appears to be enjoying a better retirement than the real one did.

Beyond that hallway, beneath the warm pendant lights of the dining room, the Italian-American history shifts from celebrities and caricatures to something much more personal. Historical family photos line the walls, including one enormous gathering that immediately captured my attention. I’m obviously not related to anyone in the picture, but I could have sworn several of the faces belonged to my own cousins, great-aunts, uncles, and grandparents. There’s something strangely familiar about an old Italian family photo, even when it isn’t your Italian family.

That history eventually catches up with the present on the cover of the menu, where a more recent photo shows Sal’s family. His sons Frank and Salvatore have since taken over the day-to-day operation, carrying Papa Luigi’s into the next generation.

A Quick Word About The Pizza

Before getting into what we ordered on this particular visit, I want to address the pizza. I’ve had Papa Luigi’s tavern-style pizza plenty of times over the last few years, and, at least among the places I’ve tried, it has become one of my favorite options on Milwaukee’s south side. Vinchi’s is right there with it, but Papa Luigi’s gets the slight edge for the more traditional atmosphere. I won’t be ordering pizza for this feature, but I’d be remiss not to highlight it as a must-try for anyone who hasn’t yet visited Papa Luigi’s.

Two Plates, Plenty Of Leftovers

For this meal, though, I wanted to stray away from my usual order and see what else the kitchen had to offer. I went with the pasta primavera, while my wife ordered the spaghetti and meatballs, though we shared enough of both that ownership became pretty loose once the plates hit the table.

My pasta primavera arrived piled with grilled chicken, broccoli, peas, zucchini, carrots, parmesan, and enough garlic to make its presence known immediately. It was rich without feeling especially heavy, with the vegetables and chicken doing enough work to keep the dish bright and balanced.

Perhaps this is sacrilegious to some readers, but I rarely if ever order spaghetti and meatballs at a restaurant. For me, that dish has always been firmly rooted in home cooking. Like many, making marinara was an important family tradition. Spaghetti was the sort of meal I grew up thinking as something you ate at home, not something you went out for. So it usually never occurs to me to order it. Shelby, however, had no such hang-up and went straight for the spaghetti and meatballs, which worked out well for me because we were sharing anyway.

Two gargantuan meatballs sat on top of a mount of spaghetti under a blanket of red sauce and parmesan. The sauce leaned slightly sweet and peppery, while the meatballs were dense, savory, garlicky, and kissed with hints of basil.

The garlic bread, meanwhile, was simple but exactly what I wanted it to be: crisp at the edges, soft in the middle but sturdy enough to serve as the ultimate edible utensil. Frankly, there may be no better spoon for sopping up whatever sauce the pasta failed to grab. I’ve had garlic bread lately that was so doused in butter that it felt like it could be wrung out like a bar rag after close. Papa Luigi’s kept things far more restrained, and better for it.

Another small detail I appreciated came at the very end of the meal: pillow mints. You don’t see them that often anymore, but there’s something satisfying about ending a big Italian dinner with one of those chalky little peppermint squares wrapped within a tiny note of “Grazie,” which felt like an ideal punctuation mark.

The portions were large enough that both of us left with boxes, which only worked in our favor. One of the first lessons I learned making spaghetti sauce with my grandfather and father was that sauce almost always tastes better after a night or two in the refrigerator, when the flavors have time to settle in and get a little more romantic with one another. I finished the pasta primavera for breakfast the next morning, because leftover pasta is one of the great underrated breakfasts. I polished off the spaghetti and meatballs around midnight the following night. Both held up beautifully.

A Neighborhood Place That Endures

In a world with too many Olive Gardens and too many restaurants trying to reinvent themselves every few years, Papa Luigi’s occupies an increasingly endangered category: the independent, family-run neighborhood restaurant that simply knows what it is. The pizza is great. The portions are big. The room feels lived in. The family history is right there on the walls. Nothing about it feels overly focus-grouped, and that is exactly the point. More than 40 years on, the Purpora family is still serving Cudahy, one pizza, plate of pasta, and gargantuan meatball at a time.

Want more Milwaukee Record? Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter and/or support us on Patreon.