The Classic from Allie Boys (lox)

Lobster roll from St. Paul's

Pork chop sandwich from the pork place at the State Fair

Tuna salad sandwich at West Allis Cheese and Sausage

Hot ham and rolls

Anything made by Cory the Riverwest Sandwich Fixer. (He did not pay me to post this. Yet.)

Don't sleep on the club sandwich at Gus's Deli.  Damn tasty, damn huge.  Go soon - Gus is about to retire.

the salmon sandwich at Blue Star!

@hot-hamski 100% on the Lobster Roll from St. Paul's Fish Co. Definitely in my top 5.

I saw Benji's get a mention so I have to give props to the Gonzo.

Thirded on the St. Paul's lobster roll.

Suburpia. 

Cloud Red's chicken or tofu po'boy. 

Honestly, I also really like the pre-made/packaged Glorioso's muffaletta even though, yes, probably technically the fresh one is "better". 

Lobster Roll from St Pauls-Definitely

Cheezy Joe From WA Cheese and Sausage - Don't know why but I"m addicted to it

Grebe's Ham on anything-FYI Perspective Brewing in WA serves Grebe's ham and rolls on Saturday am if you join them to watch soccer.  It's a lot of fun

@mkehippo414 whats on the Cheezy Joe from WA Cheese & Sausage?

Forgot to mention; Xankia's Bahn Mi. Been too long since I've had one.

@drawkward I gotta put this on my list!

@mitchyd Basically a grilled cheese with sloppy joe.  sounds basic but for some reason it just hits the spot.  The sloppy joe isn't too sweet.  Just blends well

I saw the Gonzo mentioned and that's a big one for me. I don't think Benji's gets enough love in general, but that place is awesome. Also I get the chicken cesar sandwich at Nessun Dorma probably once a month because it is delicious and also because it is very close to my house.